No Extradition for Polanski

[annaj26]

Roman Polanski: Polish court rejects US extradition


A court in Krakow has ruled against a US request to extradite film director Roman Polanski for having had sex with a 13-year-old girl there in the 1970s.

Judge Dariusz Mazur said the request was "inadmissible".

Polanski was not present in court on Friday. Prosecutors can still appeal against the ruling.

The Oscar-winning director, who admitted unlawful sex with a minor, fled from the US ahead of sentencing in 1978.

The 82-year-old has French and Polish citizenship. He lives in France - which does not extradite its own citizens - but has been working in Poland on a film project.

Swiss authorities turned down a US extradition warrant in 2010, after placing Polanski under house arrest for nine months.

The film director's Polish lawyers had argued against his extradition, citing claimed legal flaws in the US process and the 42 days Polanski served in prison at the time, according to the Associated Press news agency.

Polanski grew up in Poland and is regarded as one of the country's greatest living artists.

He survived World War Two in the Krakow ghetto but his mother died at Auschwitz.

Polish voters elected a conservative government at the weekend - and officials from the Law and Justice party had said Polanski should be sent to America to face justice.

If a Polish court were to rule in favour of extradition, the final decision would rest with the justice secretary.

1977: Polanski is arrested and charged with a string of offences relating to sex with a 13-year-old girl. These charges are dropped after he pleads guilty to unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor in a plea bargain.

1978: Fearing that he may face a lengthy jail term, Polanski flees to the UK and then to France. A citizen of France, he is protected by the country's limited extradition with the US.

2009: The US rejects Polanski's request for the case to be dismissed. Visiting Switzerland later that year, he is jailed, then placed under house arrest following a US extradition request.

2010: Swiss authorities decide against extraditing Polanski and free him.

2014: Polanski is questioned by prosecutors in Poland, acting on a US request. He agrees to comply with the Polish justice system as it examines the matter.


www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-34675672

[Jessiealan]

In my opinion they should let this go. Of course, he should have left the little girls alone, but even the "victim" wants to forget about it and does not seem damaged at all.

Polanski is an older man now and should be able to live out his life in freedom. Others may disagree.

[mouse]

if the woman who was the girl in the case doesn't wish to proceed then what is the point of carrying on
and if memory serves the case was more to do will politicking than unlawful sex and if memory is correct the girl was a willing partner?
will any sort of justice be done by dragging this up again and exactly whose interests will be served
sometimes things just have to be let go
I detest pedos and the damage they do...BUT there are times when there is a grey area and I believe this is one of them...

[Sysop3]

UPDATE



Roman Polanski's victim, Samantha Geimer, says she's "very pleased" a Polish court rejected a U.S. extradition request for the famed director, calling the decades-long legal battle a "travesty" that has brought unnecessary harm.

U.S. prosecutors have repeatedly tried to extradite Polanski over his 1977 sex-crime conviction. When a Polish judge on Friday rejected the latest extradition request, Polanski said he felt "relief" — a sentiment Geimer echoed.

"I believe they did the right thing and made the right decision given all the facts," she told NBC News in an exclusive interview. "Since I'm well aware of how long this has been going on, I'm very pleased and happy."

Geimer, 52, said that's partially for "selfish" reasons — the media attention around each twist and turn of the nearly 40-year saga has been horrible for her and her family.

"Everyone wants to use the most sensational words they can," she explained in a phone interview. "It's unpleasant to be talked about in those terms."

She's also mindful of how the case has impacted Polanski and his loved ones, even if she doesn't feel she knows him "personally" so many years later.

"I'm sure he's a nice man and I know he has a family and I think he deserves closure and to be allowed to put this behind him," Geimer said. "He said he did it, he pled guilty, he went to jail. I don't know what people want from him."

Polanski was accused of plying his then-13-year-old victim with champagne and drugs at a Los Angeles photo shoot, taking topless photos and having sex with her. He pleaded guilty to unlawful sex with a minor in 1977 and served 42 days in prison.

The acclaimed filmmaker fled the country the following year out of fear the judge would overrule the deal and send him back behind bars — and U.S. authorities have been pursuing him ever since.

The result, Geimer told NBC News, has put her and Polanski in an unlikely place.

"We somehow ended up on the same side," she explained. "Things have to go pretty wrong for them to end up this way."

According to Geimer, the case has been an expensive and torturous attempt at grabbing headlines instead of pursuing justice.

"It's a joke. A travesty," she said. "Hollywood justice at its finest."

That's why she wants the L.A. County District Attorney to stop pursuing extradition and to "honor the deal that was made" — or sentence Polanski in absentia to time served.

The district attorney's office also should be investigating allegations of prosecutorial misconduct which have dogged the case and been central to Polanski's legal strategy, Geimer said.

However, Los Angeles County District Attorney Jackie Lacey told The Associated Press after Friday's ruling that she was disappointed but would continue to pursue the case "because justice has never been served."

To Geimer, that's "doing a disservice" to the people of Los Angeles.

"If they're going to waste time and money they should be spending it on helping people right now, today, that need help — not going for a publicity grab at everybody else's expense," she said. "Right now something terrible is happening to someone in Los Angeles — right now a woman needs help."

That doesn't mean Geimer has forgotten what happened.

"There's absolutely no way to not call it rape because that's what it was," she said of the 1977 incident that launched the legal battle. "But I recovered from what happened that night a long time ago… Bad stuff happens to people. Worse stuff happens to people."

What came after the rape — the legal machinations, sensational headlines, endless news cycle — was also deeply traumatic, Geimer noted, and it's still not over for her or Polanski.

"I feel a kinship with him having been through this," she said. "He has apologized to me, he has treated me kindly and with respect, and I'm unaware that he's ever done anything untoward to anyone else."


www.nbcnews.com/news/world/roman-polanskis-victim-samantha-geimer-reacts-extradition-ruling-n455011

[Jessiealan]

It is obvious to me the prosecuting attorney is trying to use this case to build a name for herself.

They should let it go. Polanski is elderly now and has done nothing destructive that we know of for many years.

[mouse]

it always seemed to me that it was a bit of a witch hunt on Polansky that for some on some where it had become personal...